EC Skid Plate

[cdn280]

Being totally disappointed in the CRD skid model that has to be the dumbest design ever (hooks on the back side of the frame so when you hit the front the back falls off were it hooks on in the wrong direction), I'm looking for a replacement.
Any comments on these for slipping over logs/rocks ?
http://www.steahlyoffroad.com/skid-p...kid-plate.html
(a lot cheaper than the others)

or Scorpion
http://www.gofasters.com/index.php?m...oducts_id=6335

or Hyde plastic
http://www.gofasters.com/index.php?m...oducts_id=6340

or??

I've never ridden with a plastic bash plate before, is it too slippery and slides off when perched precariously on a wet log/rock ? The reduced noise factor is a nice benefit though.