$90 replacement rear fender? Really?

[firffighter]

Wanting to replace the rear fender on my '03 EC250. Ordered one from motorcycle superstore (polisport) and it is too bright a red and does not match the OEM color. It also would not come close to fitting without major surgery.

So, I look up a rear OEM fender on Gofaster and it is listed at over $90

So, any ideas on where to find one? May be interested in side panels too, but afraid to look